HOME | MAIN BOARD | JIM'S BLOG | LOGIN | REGISTER | SEARCH | FLAT MODE

not logged in

re: Jim AND Meat

Posted by:
subgeniuszero (john.constantine@mac.com) 06:20 am MST 01/27/07
In reply to: re: Jim AND Meat - daveake 05:43 pm MST 01/26/07

Yes, I agree with what's been said. Tanz der Vampire is admittedly Steinman's best work by himself, but I honestly think his best work with Meat - and his most consistent work - was on Bat II.

Just my thoughts.

> Quite so. It's arguable, but my opinion is that the best
> representation of Jim's work is Tanz der Vampire, so I
> don't believe that his best work has been with Meat,
> though Bat 1 is a very close second.
>
> I've seen Meat several times, from back in '82 to RAH last
> year. His voice at the live shows hasn't been anywhere
> near as good as it was in the studio on Bat 1. It's
> always been a disappointment. Compare that with (for
> example) Elaine singing IACBTMN in March, which was simply
> stunning. Now there's someone who has always been able to
> do Jim's songs justice.
>
> Dave

URL: The Andyverse

reply |

Previous: re: Jim AND Meat - daveake 05:43 pm MST 01/26/07
Next: Cry Over Me as 3rd single - Pudding 03:43 pm MST 01/26/07

Thread:



    HOME | MAIN BOARD | JIM'S BLOG | LOG OFF | START A NEW THREAD | EDIT PROFILE | SEARCH | FLAT MODE