HOME | MAIN BOARD | TWITTER | LOGIN | REGISTER | SEARCH | FLAT MODE

not logged in

re: another stupid question

Posted by:
pidunk 10:23 am UTC 06/10/07
In reply to: re: another stupid question - ricgough 01:13 am UTC 06/10/07



>
> It was good on the other
> > hand, to see the Boyzone phenomenon happen with No Matter
> > What.
> Boyzone 'phenomenon' happened well before NMW. The fact
> they were so huge in U.K. & Ireland certainly helped the
> single along.

I was not intending to make a comment about Boyzone the band or THEIR phenomenon, but the phenomenon that they had that charting with No Matter What. There are reasons why such should never have taken place: number one, it is a boy band, number two it is a stage show extract, and number three it was not the most bombastic production one could have imagined. It was where it shouldn't have been from a source that was unusual, in a production that was as unSTeinman as Steinman could put out....and all this came together and made a rousing success. THAT, to me, is a phenomenon. I do believe I could have made my meaning clearer if I had phrased it as "the phenomenon with Boyzone and No Matter What" or some such; but this is what I mean. Boy bands are not considered a phenomenon to me, but a parasitic exploitation of innocent girls' developing urges. Well, that's my opinion.


>Rinkoff's Meat Loaf version is far and away
> the most involving.

I'll have to give it a listen one of these days.


>it is far more dynamic and for me the
> definitive version.

Because of Meat Loaf, or because of the production? I suppose you'd say a little bit of both.


> B.T.W. what happened? I heard they signed for Ravenous
> (U.S. Releases) about 6 months before they 'went
> Solo'(split up!). Heard nothing notable about Ravenous
> since.

Maybe they weren't hungry. Nooo, I suppose that there is something inherently unmarketable about a split boy band.





reply |

Previous: re: another stupid question - ricgough 01:13 am UTC 06/10/07
Next: re: another stupid question - ricgough 01:45 pm UTC 06/10/07

Thread:



HOME | MAIN BOARD | LOG OFF | START A NEW THREAD | EDIT PROFILE | SEARCH | FLAT MODE