not logged in
| re: Jim needs to pull his finger out from up his arse and release some demo's ASAP | |
Posted by:  |
Pudding 08:12 pm UTC 09/10/08 |
| In reply to: | re: Jim needs to pull his finger out from up his arse and release some demo's ASAP - Smeghead 08:03 pm UTC 09/10/08 |
| I don't think Bat3 is what it should've been, I don't think Meats vocals are what they could've been and I'm tired of speculating on what would've been. But Bat3 for all its faults isn't unlistenable (well half of it isn't anyway) and Meats vocals aren't as shite you constantly are making out that they are/were. Yes Meats vocals live have taken a downward spiral and no one outside of Loafdom has ever stated that they haven't, but they aint as bad on the album like one of his live shows. The only reason you're glad Ryan is back is because he shares your twisted point of view when not many others do. > There are plenty of other people who think Bat 3 was > shit. > Ryan and me don't always agree... but I think Ryan has > grown immensely since he first arrived at this board years > ago and I'm glad he's back. Anyone should be able to hear > that Meat's vocals were better on MATLAF... just that the > songs were crap. Bat 3 has Steinman songs... but we know > how they are supposed to sound so Meat's versions are more > noticably crap. > > > You're talking bullshit Smegma, just because you have a > > follower of one (Ryan) quit the shit. > > > > > I agree with Ryan. While MATLF has crap songs, at least > > > Meat doesn't sound like a strangled turd. His voice on > > > Bat 3 is so bad it is unlistenable. Not to mention that > > > with Bat 3 you know how good the songs can sound, so > > > listening to Meat murder them makes Bat 3 unlistenable, > > > while with MATLAF you don't have anhything else to compare > > > it to. In fact though I never listen to either. > > > > > > > > Look at it from a production perspective. The songs on > > > > > TMIL, non-Steinman and all, could have sounded a lot > > > > > better. It all sounds like white noise and, well, MATLAF > > > > > doesn't. At least not to me. > > > > > > > > Yes the songs could've sounded a lot better and the > > > > production wasn't what Jim would have done. But all that > > > > being said, it still aint a better album than MATLAF. If > > > > you call it white noise then you've never heard white > > > > noise, I've heard white noise for several hours at a time > > > > and Bat3 don't sound like that. | |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | re: Jim needs to pull his finger out from up his arse and release some demo's ASAP - Smeghead 08:03 pm UTC 09/10/08 |
| Next: | re: Jim needs to pull his finger out from up his arse and release some demo's ASAP - Smeghead 08:27 pm UTC 09/10/08 |
| Thread: |
|