| The Nothing Sacred Debate | |
|
Posted by: |
steven_stuart 12:54 am UTC 11/19/10 |
| In reply to: | Nothing Sacred Celene Dion - Marklbetya 03:04 am UTC 11/15/10 |
| Gosh. There's a lot of debate in the comments section. DoctorX777 wrote: "This is nice enough, but it doesn't have the raw power of Meat Loaf and Patti Russo's version. In this one Dion sounds like she keeps trying to rock out, but neither her voice nor the music are suited to it. Personal taste, I guess." Someone replies: "She lacks the raw power? Did you even play the entire song? The second half of the song blows everyone away. Celine is a Rock icon esp in the French world . This song is only a demo and not a proper commercial recording." MrDamian wrote: "Celine Dion record this as demo in 1998, but she had some kind of a thing about wanting the writers to pay a fee to have her sing their songs, which was chickenshit of her, if you ask me. Jim Steinman didn't want to pay, so he turn-around and produced the song for Meat Loaf's Very Best Of." Someone further down the page writes something absolutely horrible about Meat Loaf. I won't repeat it here but click on the link below if you want to join in the debate. My personal opinion is that I love Celine's version of "IACBTMN" and I also prefered the video (but not necessarily the song itself) to the Pandora's Box video of "IACBTMN". Celine's video was simple and to the point and I believe that she served the song well by doing that. Although I must stress that this is just my opinion. I do think its a great shame that Jim fell out with her when they were doing so well together. Jim has production credits on the two best selling Celine albums of all time (both are in the top twenty best selling albums of all time list). | |
| URL: | The Nothing Sacred Debate |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | Nothing Sacred Celene Dion - Marklbetya 03:04 am UTC 11/15/10 |
| Next: | Top 10 Jim Songs - WarioLoaf 11:07 pm UTC 11/14/10 |
| Thread: | |