not logged in
| re: The demos of JIm singing | |
Posted by:  |
rockfenris2005 07:25 am UTC 04/26/11 |
| In reply to: | re: The demos of JIm singing - The_wolf_with_the_red_roses 10:57 pm UTC 04/25/11 |
I actually agree with this haha. And if it's not as simple as you say it is, I wish it were. But the question is, would Meat Loaf have recorded the third greatest selling rock album of all time with somebody else's songs? Would it have been as popular? I don't think it would have been as special. "Rat out of Purgatory Songs by Diane Warren" *The boy who left home to find out all about the shudders would shudder at this* > Um....your opinion. Simply your opinion. I'm entitled to > mine thanks ever so much. Elaborate on where I'm wrong or > , what part of that statement doesn't ring true. Without > Jim there would be no songs, thus meaning there would be > no Bat Out Of Hell at all. If Meat hadn't been the singer, > they would have found someone else. Might be hard for you > get your head around, but as far Bat Out of Hell goes, Jim > irreplaceable and is the be all and end all of that album. > because he wrote the songs, his songs, his vision, his > album. > > An actor recently dropped out of the making of The Hobbit > movie. Now, he probably auditioned for that movie, went to > several call backs before eventually getting the part. Now > he;s gone, you think they'll leave the character he was > set to play out of the movie because he was the only who > could play it. Course not, there gonna get someone else. > Just like Jim and Todd would have done, would it have been > as special? I believe so, perhaps in a different way but I > believe Jim's music would have made whoever sang in > Meat's place perform it to the best of their ability and > beyond it. > > Let me ask you something, could there have been a Bat Out > Of Hell without Jim? No, there couldn't have been. Now, > the same question but with Meat's name instead of Jim's, > like it or not, would have a different answer. > > Jim's music is more fresh and less shrouded in nostalgia > for me, in other words, I value my opinion a hell of alot > more then yours !. > > > > > > "Without Jim, we wouldn't be having this debate in the > > first place, his music has given us so much to talk about > > and it gave Meat the start of his successful carrer. > > Without Meat, Jim would have found someone else, and we'd > > be having this debate about someone else being as > > important to Bat Out of Hell as Jim is. " > > > > > > > > Um... No. Simply no. Youre wrong. | |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | re: The demos of JIm singing - The_wolf_with_the_red_roses 10:57 pm UTC 04/25/11 |
| Next: | re: The demos of JIm singing - The_wolf_with_the_red_roses 07:01 pm UTC 04/27/11 |
| Thread: |
|