> > Jim did an OK job, but I can see why he works
> > with other singers. And "Left In The Dark" should've been
> > left to Rory.
>
> I like how shaky Jim's voice is during that song, it makes
> it much more emotional. It sounds like he's almost crying
> the whole song. I think a version with real power--like
> Meat--would make it sound more like a song and less like
> an experience. With Jim it sounds like you're there.
I agree with that- and the spoken word parts are ONLY found (as far as I know) on his version, and they really make the song for me. Then again, after the third or fourth time through the album, i had gotten quite attached to Jim's voice.
|
