HOME | MAIN BOARD | TWITTER | LOGIN | REGISTER | SEARCH | THREADED MODE

not logged in

Threaded Order | Chronological Order

Heresy

Posted by:
fnord 11:41 am MST 12/07/18
The only objection I've ever had to the content of a Jim Steinman song is one line in "Good Girls Go To Heaven," specifically the phrase, "Somebody told me so." I've always found this uncomfortably ambiguous. I realize the line parallels the quote from "A Kiss Is A Terrible Thing To Waste," "Tell them your mama said so." Of course, a line like "My mother told me so" in a song about teenage rebellion and debauchery would present a different discomfort factor.

Still, I wonder what Jim could have used instead to create a romantic image in the song. "The angels told me so" fits the meter and the heavenly atmosphere; he could even have alternated it with "The devil told me so" in the following verse, similar to phrasing in other songs like "Cold."

Of course, singing something like, "The voices told me so" would give the song a completely different meaning.



reply to this message |

re: Heresy

Posted by:
fnord 10:42 am MST 08/30/19
In reply to: Heresy - fnord 11:41 am MST 12/07/18
So there I was, blathering on about BDSM on Twitter, as one does...

Hey, has Jim ever said anything about BDSM? There are hints of it throughout his works, but nothing I recall straightforwardly embracing it. Just curious.

Anyway, there I was, blathering on about how to pronounce BDSM, and would it be better calling it SMBD so we can pronounce it "sumbud." I came up with the word "somebuddy" as one's SMBD play partner. Isn't that sweet?

Then I realized _this_ is what Jim wrote in Good Girls Go To Heaven: "SOMEBUDDY told me so!" Her kinky play partner told her bad girls go everywhere. Now it all makes sense.


reply to this message |




HOME | MAIN BOARD | LOG OFF | START A NEW THREAD | EDIT PROFILE | SEARCH | FLAT MODE