not logged in
| re: The Anatomy Of Research, Or, Why Not Just Doodle? | |
Posted by:  |
pidunk 11:45 pm UTC 05/25/07 |
| In reply to: | re: The Anatomy Of Research, Or, Why Not Just Doodle? - GTKarber 08:07 pm UTC 05/25/07 |
> That is not a live recording of Jim singing, for Christ's > sake. It is the RECORDED SONG with both of them singing > along to it. There are DRUMS AND BACKUP VOCALISTS, despite > the fact that Jim is only playing piano. There are several clips to chose from in the page link I provided, http://jimsteinman.com/ladybirds.htm. One of them, the one on the bottom, is exactly as you say it is. It is called ladybirds4.rm, and it is the finished version I referred to, and is not the song development that I was referring to. Let me identify that clip for you which I am referring to. Jim coaches Bonnie's singing and during that course he is also singing the part. Where is Rory Dodd in those rehearsals? I am certain that you have seen it after all of the love you have of Jim and coming daily to his website. There are four videos on the page, why not look at the first on the top to the fourth on the bottom, and look at the anatomy of the song development, then look at where Rory is in all of it, and tell me where you see him. Asking the same question asked by Jacob. Why would Jim lipsynch to Rory's vocals? (Jacob was wondering why Rory would lip synch to Jim's vocals). You just want something further than this. If Jim told you that he sang the "Turn Around" on the song, a statement that is publicly lacking in the face of the visual actions of that demonstration which assumes you would see it for yourself, would you then believe? If all that is lacking is Jim's say so, then, say so here. > > Even if you think Jim is enough of a talent and a genius > to write Rocky Horror and sing Rory Dodd's parts on his > songs, I want to know how you believe him to be talented > enough to play drums, back-up vocals (five or six of > them), and THUNDER (for Christ's sake) on a piano. I know > all that I can play on a piano is piano, but maybe Jim > possesses this amazing and singular talent. > > You obviously do not know what Parsimony and Occam's Razor > are. Please look them up and pretend to know what they > mean for your next response. > > Thank you very much. | |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | I May Fail At Occam's Razor, But I Apply Parsimony : A "P" For Effort! - pidunk 01:39 am UTC 05/26/07 |
| Next: | re: The Anatomy Of Research, Or, Why Not Just Doodle? - Jacob 06:30 pm UTC 05/25/07 |
| Thread: | |