HOME | MAIN BOARD | JIM'S BLOG | LOGIN | REGISTER | SEARCH | FLAT MODE

not logged in

re: Graveyard v Bad For Good

Posted by:
Smeghead (rockmanREMOVETHIS@realmofdreams.com) 09:36 am MST 01/31/07
In reply to: re: Graveyard v Bad For Good - Scaramouche 09:15 am MST 01/31/07

I Don't know what you are talking about... it is exactly the same melody...

> I've just played along to the track, using the B4G sheet
> music, and you are right in that the Graveyard verse chord
> structure is the same as the 'god speed' chords, but the
> melody is different, which makes it 'new' in my
> eyes/ears.
>
> Thousands of songs use the same chord structure, but if
> the melody is different, the song is different or 'new'.
>
> The pre-chorus starting 'and I see it all...', and the
> chorus starting 'Maybe it's a curse...' seem definately
> new to me, unless you can point out the corresponding
> parts in B4G ?
>
> I've never been overly bothered with Jim's recycling, as
> he seems to put a lot of effort into making a completely
> new piece, as opposed to just a minor alteration on an old
> piece.
>
> I think they could both work in Bat, as long as the 'god
> speed' parts are removed from Graveyard.
>
> >
> >
> > > 1. The verses & chorus in Graveyard are totally different
> > > to Bad For Good, the ONLY connection being the 'god speed'
> > > parts.
> >
> > No, it is almost entirely the exact same music... liten
> > again. Perhaps you can't hear it because it is piano
> > only.

URL: Realm Of Dreams

reply |

Previous: re: Graveyard v Bad For Good - Scaramouche 09:15 am MST 01/31/07
Next: re: Answering Jim's OTHER questions - John_Galt 04:44 pm MST 01/29/07

Thread:



    HOME | MAIN BOARD | JIM'S BLOG | LOG OFF | START A NEW THREAD | EDIT PROFILE | SEARCH | FLAT MODE