| re: Confusion about the new interview | |
|
Posted by: |
HellsFinest 09:20 pm UTC 10/03/07 |
| In reply to: | re: Confusion about the new interview - tragichippy 09:06 am UTC 10/03/07 |
| that's cool... i am just saying that to me, his performance on 'Monster' stirs my own emotions... far more than any of the non 'Bat' material.... and that is admirable for an old man who really can't sing anymore... and i applaud him for the effort and am grateful for the few gems that came from the record.... :) > > > > it's all about the emotion... the technical merits are not > > the most important thing (to me anyway)... Meat really > > sings his heart out, and that means alot to me... that can > > be said about the whole 'Monster' record... it may not be > > a great record on the technical front, but it is a very > > emotional record... and i love that... > > > really? put to the aside all the hoo-hah surrounding the > lack of Jim, the presence of Desmond, the quality of > Meat's voice, i think my biggest problem with this album > is the lack of emotion in the songs. > > i think the songs on TMIL are better than those on > Midnight and CHSIB and maybe even the other non-Jim > albums, but it sits at the bottom of the list, because for > me, on this album, THERE IS NO EMOTION. > > personally speaking that's what stops me getting into it. > i can get past the fake Bat thing, i only ever refer to it > as TMIL, but i can't get past the lack of meaning. he > seems to be going through the motions if you ask me. i > prefer CHSIB, not because the songs are any good (half the > album is godawful), but because at least Meat 'seems' like > he cares... > > that is all. | |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | re: Confusion about the new interview - tragichippy 09:06 am UTC 10/03/07 |
| Next: | re: Confusion about the new interview - Pudding 02:05 am UTC 10/04/07 |
| Thread: |
|