| re: Bonnie Tyler Album: New Songs or Old? | |
|
Posted by: |
Leesa (gallytrotter@mchsi.com) 02:10 am UTC 10/24/07 |
| In reply to: | Bonnie Tyler Album: New Songs or Old? - Bright_Eyes 06:03 pm UTC 10/23/07 |
| Oh my god. You are absolutely correct, Bright Eyes. The last CD of hers was so bad I destroyed it myself so no one else would hear Jim that way. It had I think (you have to understand that my memory is bad and in my mid-forties it's worse!)'Making Love Out of Nothing at all' and maybe 'Two Outta 3' on it and they were desecrated horrendously. Really made me realise that Jim doesn't walk on water. Pimp daddy. Bonnie's voice needs to retire with some dignity and the songs he wrote that 'made it' need to get retired with an ounce of intergrity. Your comments or spot-on. Jim is a damned fool to commit new coveted material to a, sorry, but 'has been' vocally. Composers stretch beyond the vehicle for their work and Jim should. By the way, I do apologise for accusing you of being Susan. That was not correct. I don't accuse 'without a shred of evidence'. Nor was your interpretation of my 'fanatical hatred' correct. That I do not have. You misunderstand. I think you tried to support her in your way whilst she was here. We don't agree on methods but points you make are very valid and I do respect your interpretations on Jim. And here that should rule. Leesa J > In her interview, Bonnie Tyler said Steinman has promised > to provide one or two songs for her next album, to be done > in 2008. > > I saw somebody, forgot who, say they hope it's not just > another remix of Total Eclipse. Personally, I hope it is, > or at least a re-mix of some other old song. Hell, I hope > Jim changes his mind and bails out of the project. > > I think Bonnie Tyler's singing has declined considerably > in quality, and any new Steinman songs would be wasted on > her. > > Any new Steinman songs that do exist should go to either > to the Bat musical (if completed and worthy) or to a > singer who is still in his or her prime. Preferably not to > any of the singers who've already released Steinman songs, > and not to the Dream-Engine. Although, if they went to the > Dream-Engine the singing would at least be of good > quality. > > Discuss. | |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | Bonnie Tyler Album: New Songs or Old? - Bright_Eyes 06:03 pm UTC 10/23/07 |
| Next: | re: Bonnie Tyler Album: New Songs or Old? - Bright_Eyes 05:24 am UTC 10/24/07 |
| Thread: |
|