I agree with Ryan. While MATLF has crap songs, at least Meat doesn't sound like a strangled turd. His voice on Bat 3 is so bad it is unlistenable. Not to mention that with Bat 3 you know how good the songs can sound, so listening to Meat murder them makes Bat 3 unlistenable, while with MATLAF you don't have anhything else to compare it to. In fact though I never listen to either.
> > Look at it from a production perspective. The songs on
> > TMIL, non-Steinman and all, could have sounded a lot
> > better. It all sounds like white noise and, well, MATLAF
> > doesn't. At least not to me.
>
> Yes the songs could've sounded a lot better and the
> production wasn't what Jim would have done. But all that
> being said, it still aint a better album than MATLAF. If
> you call it white noise then you've never heard white
> noise, I've heard white noise for several hours at a time
> and Bat3 don't sound like that.
|
