I don't have any problem with the quality of the adaptation that Scaramouche has made, but I do feel there is a difference between adapting a work, and interpreting it.
> Hey cool, thanks for the comment!
>
> The piano riff definately says 'dance sequence on stage'
> to me, and most of the lyrics prompted my Peter Pan
> suggestion.
>
> Definately one of my fav Steinman songs, especially the
> 'wail'.
>
> Also it doesn't matter if the Rhinegold vision doesn't
> work for others, it's your vision and that's all that
> matters!
>
>
> > I'm just saying that it's my interpretation. The original
> > poster made his with his excellent piece of dialogue. We
> > all know that Jim wrote the songs with a certain imagery
> > and purpose in mind, but we can't help what we take from
> > the music as we hear it. I'm not trying to say mine's the
> > definitive image, or that I should have written it instead
> > of Steinman (how presumptuous and rude) I'm just saying
> > that's what I see, I saw it working at the climax of
> > "Rhinegold".
> >
> > Surely there's nothing wrong with having an
> > interpretation? Because that's all I was saying.
> >
> >
|
