not logged in
| re: The demos of JIm singing | |
Posted by:  |
LordRahl 11:08 am UTC 04/19/11 |
| In reply to: | re: The demos of JIm singing - The_wolf_with_the_red_roses 08:53 am UTC 04/19/11 |
| I would never tell someone not to follow their dreams, don't know why you think that. I'm one of those "records are made to be broken" types of people, so have at it. And I don't know why you think I feel meat is the end all be all. I think they are equal contributors to that album, bringing their A game. It's a group effort and just because you hear Todd Rundgren say meat did nothing but sit in a corner the whole time, well that's just an out right lie. I think Ted Neeley was just as important to the role of Jesus in JCS as ALW and Rice was in creating it. Meat is just as important to bat as Jim, just in a different way. Case in point, go sing all the songs on the album, record it, sell it, see how well it does. > Using the whole "I've been listening to them longer" > translates to me that your blinded by nostalgia and not > seeing my point. If you do and disagree that's fine. I > will not be told by you or anyone else that my view is > less validated then yours because I found Jim's music more > recently then you. Say I'm an idiot all you want, truth > is, you cant argue back because my view however harsh is a > valid one. > > At no point did I say Meat's performance was bad, I just > dont think its a key factor in why the albums are great. > The songs are what make it great, as long as someone can > sing, Jim's music brings the emotion out of the performer. > Jim has an ability that I aspire to have one day, I can > hear you typing away and snickering as you write "You as > good as Jim, HA!" or something to that effect. But to me, > what Jim can do is another league to what Meat can do. > Something altogether better then what Meat's. Call that > what you will, blind faith, fanboy-ism or whatever you > wish. In my opinion, what Jim did and continues to do will > always be more inspiring and amazing then singing. That's > how I feel, sorry if I dont agree with you that Meat is > some sort of marvel who is the only one who sings Jim's > songs right. In my view, Meat should only sing what Jim > gives him, if that means waiting a few years then the man > should wait, he'd be waiting for the best if he did it. | |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | re: The demos of JIm singing - Klasien 09:39 am UTC 04/20/11 |
| Next: | re: The demos of JIm singing - The_wolf_with_the_red_roses 07:17 pm UTC 04/21/11 |
| Thread: |
|